中医药研究论丛

271.4《金匮要略》「肺死脏」重新诠释
TJ TCM.27(1) : 39-51, 2024 39
DOI : 10.6516/TJTCM.202403_27(1).0004 
《金匮要略》「肺死脏」重新诠释
Reinterpretation of “Dead Lung” in the Synopsis of Golden Chamber
张永明1,2,3 吕冠恩4 吕平安5 陈冠宇6 张家诚7,*
1 一品堂丰原中医诊所,台中
2 义守大学医学院,学士後中医学系,高雄
3 义守大学医学院,中医部,高雄
4 中国医药大学,中医学系,台中
5 彰化基督教医院,中医部,彰化
6 马偕纪念医院,中医部,台北
7 义守大学医学院,物理治疗学系,高雄
【摘要】
背景:《金匮要略・五脏风寒积聚病脉证并治第十一》:「肺死藏,浮之虚,按之弱,如葱叶,下无根者,死」,文仅17字,由於缺乏关键证候,导致医家诠释存在诸多疑点,影响「肺死脏」的诊断与临床实用。
目的:厘订并重新诠释「肺死脏」。
方法:典籍考证,结合西医解剖、影像学。
结果:
1.「肺死脏」记录肺脏由正常生理转变为死脏的病理过程,并非仅描述脉象变化。
2.「浮之虚」指肺脏在正常生理状态之下会充满气体,呈现空虚状态,可飘浮在水面上。
3.「按之弱」是从解剖角度观察肺脏组织,指性质按压脆弱的特色。
4.「如葱叶」描述「肺死脏」的病理型态,相当於西医特发性肺纤维化在高解析度肺部电脑断层下呈现的「蜂窝肺」特徵,显示当时医家有观察到「肺死脏」之肺部解剖病理构造,才能精准描绘「如葱叶」。
5.「下无根」指肺泡间质纤维化後导致肺泡逐渐丧失气体交换的功能,最後因肺功能衰竭而死亡。
6.以王叔和《脉经・热病五藏气绝死日证第二十二》中「热病,肺气绝……肺先死」六大证候:(1)喘逆,(2)欬,(3)唾血,(4)手足腹肿,(5)面黄,(6)振栗不能言语,弭补未臻完整的「肺死脏」症状表现。
结论:《金匮要略》「肺死脏」记录肺脏由正常生理转变成特发性肺纤维化的病理过程。
【关键词】肺死脏、葱叶、特发性肺纤维化
Yung-Ming Chang1,2,3 Kuan-En Lu4 Ping-An Lu5
Kuan-Yu Chen6 Chia-Cheng Chang7,*
1 1PT Fengyuan Chinese Medicine Clinics, Taichung 404, Taiwan
2 The School of Chinese Medicine for Post-Baccalaureate, I-Shou University, Kaohsiung 840, Taiwan
3 Chinese Medicine Department, E-Da Hospital, Kaohsiung 824, Taiwan
4 School of Chinese Medicine, China Medical University, Taichung 404, Taiwan
5 Department of Chinese Medicine, Changhua Christian Hospital (CCH), Changhua 500, Taiwan
6 Department of Chinese Medicine, MacKay Memorial Hospital, Taipei 104, Taiwan
7 Department of Physical Therapy, I-SHOU University, Kaohsiung 824, Taiwan
【Summary】
Background: Chapter XI of the Synopsis of Golden Chamber: “Pulse of Dead Lung is deficient when pressed lightly and as weak and rootless as the leaves of a Chinese onion when pressed deeply. This indicates a fatal case.” Only 17 words, but the lack of critical syndrome has led to many doubts in the interpretation, which affects the iagnosis of the “Dead Lung” and therapeutic usefulness.
Purpose: Define and reinterpret the “Dead Lung”.
Methods: Classics research and integration of anatomy and Radiology.
Results:
1. “Dead Lung” describes the pathological transformation of the lungs rom normal to failure, not just a description of pulse changes.
2. “Deficient when ressed lightly” means that the lungs in physiological state are full of gas and appear o be empty, floating on the water surface.
3. “Weak when pressed deeply” is an natomical view of the lung tissue, which is fragile.
4. “As the leaves of a Chinese nion” describes the pathological pattern of “Dead Lung” as comparable to thehoneycomb lung” characteristic of Idiopathic Pulmonary Fibrosis (IPF) under high esolution computed tomography, indicating that doctors at that time had observed
the anatomical pathology of “Dead Lung” in order to accurately depict the term.
5.Rootless when pressed deeply” refers to the gradual loss of gas exchange following nterstitial fibrosis of the lung and eventual death from lung failure. 6. Chapter XXII
of the Maijing written by Wang Shuhe, the six symptoms of “The Lung Qi is exhausted due to febrile illness......the Lung Failure first” are: (1) wheezing, (2)cough, (3) spitting blood, (4) swelling of the hands, feet and abdomen, (5) yellow face,and (6) shivering and inability to speak, to make up for the lack of symptoms of “Dead Lung”.
Conclusion: The term “Dead Lung” in the Synopsis of the Golden Chamber describes the pathological transformation of the lungs from normal to IPF.
Keywords
Dead LungThe leaves of a Chinese onionIdiopathic Pulmonary Fibrosis, IPF