中医药研究论丛

253.2 舌下络脉判读模型之建立
 TJ TCM.25(3) : 1-12, 2022
舌下络脉判读模型之建立
Set up Interpretation Model of Sublingual Collateral Vessels
廖振凯1 林映筑2 谢宗翰3 胡荣辉4 黄琮融5 刘俊贤6 游明谦1,2*
1 佛教慈济医疗财团法人台北慈济医院中医部,台北,台湾
2 慈济大学学士後中医学系,台湾
3 佛教慈济医疗财团法人台北慈济医院研究部,台北,台湾
4 新北市仁爱医院新陈代谢科,新北,台湾
5 高雄医学大学附设中和纪念医院中医部,高雄,台湾
6 佛教慈济医疗财团法人花莲慈济医院中医部,花莲,台湾
【摘要】
目的:舌诊为中医四诊中「望诊」的主要内容之一,中医可以藉由舌象看出寒热虚实,气血盛衰辅助判读疾病的性质及深浅。传统舌诊着重於舌面的诊察,但舌下络脉诊法亦是中医舌诊的重要内容,其表现与血瘀症有重要相关性。在舌下络脉与中医瘀证的相关研究中,其严重程度至今尚未有很好的标准化定义。本研究尝试建构简易且有效之舌下络脉评估模式,将舌下静脉曲张的严重程度分为V1-V4 四个层级,而舌下出现的瘀点数分为P0-P2 三种严重程度,让舌下络脉能有客观化的一致性判读标准。然而经过建构舌下络脉判读模式後,不同拍摄器具、不同医师判读之差异性亦需要标准化。
方法:本研究使用七种不同手机及一单眼相机拍摄後评估差异。训练判读医师一周後,尝试建立舌下络脉判读之一致性程度。
结果:结果显示,在强制闪光前提下,经过舌下络脉判读训练完善之三位医师,在不同品牌之智慧型手机与单眼相机对於同一舌下络脉判读结果并无明显差异。舌下络脉判读之一致性方面,十位医学生经一周之教育训练後,达到良好的可信度,舌下静脉曲张组内相关系数(Intraclass correlation coefficient; ICC)为0.750,瘀点ICC 为0.719。
结论:因此本研究所建立舌下络脉严重度之标准化,可提供未来舌下络脉临床研究之叁考。
【关键词】舌下络脉、舌诊、血瘀、舌下静脉曲张、瘀点
Chen-Kai Liao1Yin-Chu Lin2Tsung-Han Hsieh3Rong-Huei Hu4
Tsung-Rong Huang5Chun-Shien Liu6Min-Chien Yu1,2*
1Department of Chinese Medicine, Taipei Tzu Chi Hospital, Buddhist Tzu Chi Medical
Foundation, Taipei, Taiwan
2Tzu Chi University School of Post-Baccalaureate Chinese Medicine, Taiwan
3Research Department, Taipei Tzu Chi Hospital, Buddhist Tzu Chi Medical Foundation Taipei, Taiwan
4Division of Metabolism and Endocrinology, Ren-Ai Hospital, New Taipei City, Taiwan
5Department of Chinese Medicine, Kaohsiung Medical University Chung-Ho Memorial Hospital,
Kaohsiung, Taiwan
6Department of Chinese Medicine, Hualien Tzu Chi Hospital, Buddhist Tzu Chi Medical
Foundation, Hualien, Taiwan
【Summary】
Objectives: Tongue diagnosis is one of the main tools of “Inspection” in the four examinations of Traditional Chinese Medicine (TCM). It is used to diagnose disease’s properties and severity based on cold, heat, deficiency, excess, and the exuberance and debilitation of the qi and blood through tongue manifestation.
Traditional tongue diagnosis focuses on examining the tongue surface. The diagnosis of sublingual collateral vessels also plays an essential role in the tongue diagnosis of TCM. Its manifestations are strongly related to blood stasis.
However, its severity in the research of sublingual collateral vessels and blood stasis has not yet been well standardized. The present study tried to set up effective standards for diagnosing sublingual collateral vessels. The sublingual varicose veins and petechiae were divided into four and three subgroups, V1-V4, and P0-2, respectively, based on their severity. As a result, the diagnosis of sublingual collateral vessels was judged objectively. Moreover, it is also necessary to standardize the difference among shooting types of equipment and evaluate physicians.
Methods: Hence, the current study assessed the difference using seven mobile
phones and one monocular camera. Each individual was trained for a week to
interpret the sublingual collateral vessels to determine the degree of consistency.
Results: The results showed that under the premise of compulsory flash, the three physicians who have been well trained in sublingual collateral vessels had no significant differences in the interpretation of the same sublingual collateral vessels with different brands of smartphones and the single-lens camera. In terms of the consistency of performance in sublingual collateral vessels, ten medical students achieved good credibility after a week of education and training. The sublingual varicose vein’s intraclass correlation coefficient (ICC) was 0.750, and the ICC of petechiae was 0.719.
Conclusions: Therefore, the standardized model established in this study for the severity of sublingual collateral vessels can be used as a reference for future clinical research on sublingual collateral vessels.
【Keywords】Sublingual collateral vessels; Tongue diagnosis; Blood stasis; Sublingual varicose veins; Petechiae